Speaking Up & Objecting to the Use of Psychological Safety

Speaking Up & Objecting to the Use of Psychological Safety

I’m not objecting to psychological safety. I’m objecting to the use of an incomplete solution being presented as a completed one.

Since Google’s Project Aristotle brought psychological safety into mainstream management thinking in 2016, more and more orgainsations are increasingly encouraging their people to admit mistakes, ask questions and speak up.

But I think something important is missing.

Imagine constructing a building, completing only half of it, and then encouraging people to move in.

Without the necessary safeguards, that building could become a hazard rather than a solution.

I think psychological safety faces a similar risk.

Consider someone who has tolerated objectionable behaviour from team members for weeks or months.

When they finally speak up, with the encouragement of psychological safety, how likely are they to deliver any objections calmly, without frustration, sarcasm or excessive emotion?

Now we potentially have two problems: the original objectionable behaviour from a fellow team member or their manager and the objectionable way the targeted team member objected.

One approach recommended by Amy Edmondson is to pause and reframe our interpretation of the other person’s objectionable behaviour: “It’s not about me; it’s about them.”

Think to oneself: “Perhaps the abuser is stressed, frustrated or unaware of their behaviour.”

That may help, but understanding objectionable behaviour doesn’t necessarily make it acceptable or change it.

Psychological safety encourages people to speak up. But how does one object to the objector? Who teaches us how to object well?

I am sorry, but I don’t think Amy’s advice is going to cut it in the real world.

That’s where SpatzAI comes in.

Our proposed Objection Management System gives every team member, regardless of rank, an agreed procedure to caution, object, and stop. Resolve or escalate objectionable behaviour.

Starting with a simple verbal “Caution”, it aims to address friction before frustration accumulates.

If the caution was unsuccessful then….

…the SpatzAI 3-step chat app then takes over and prompts the issuer of an objection to either resolve or escalate.

And finally the SpatzAI transparent team/peer + Ai review process to be used when their spat is still unresolved.

But here’s my verbal caution to my own proposal.

What if SpatzAI is also a half-completed building?

That’s why we need independent field trials to examine its effectiveness, fairness and potential hazards.

To collect real-world behavioural data — not just survey responses about how psychologically safe people feel, but evidence of how they actually object, respond, resolve and hold one another accountable for any objectionable behaviour.

I’m not objecting to the building. I’m objecting to declaring it ready for occupation before its safety has been established.

And that standard must apply equally to SpatzAI.

Because encouraging people to speak up is one thing.

Helping teams object well is another.

SpatzAI — Helping Teams Object Well.

Spatz.ai

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑